The lack of transparency on media ownership in brazil. Therefore, whenever a media outlet is owned by a corporation, its corporate file is made public via the commercial register. Where media companies are formally owned by the state, the government may exercise a strong influence, censoring stories, stifling investigations into. Who owns the media in ghana media ownership monitor. Georgias current regulation of the broadcasting sector has proven insufficient to ensure a transparent media ownership regime and to promote a competitive, pluralistic television market. They are based on research into the law and practice in 20 countries surveyed by access info europe and the open society program on independent journalism. In romania, transparency of media ownership is addressed directly in the constitution and is regulated by a mediaspecific. In search for better regulation of transparency of ownership and. Experts, european organisations and ngos agree that transparency of media ownership is crucial for media pluralism and democracy as, for instance, it provides the knowledge to take steps to address media concentration and conflict of interests. Media ownership and its impact on media independence and. Transparency of media ownership is an essential component of any democratic media system. Ownership transparency the role of the private sector access to information about those who own and control companies beneficial ownership information allows companies, banks, investors, professional advisors and other business users to understand who they are doing business with, their partners and their competitors. The result for the 43 analyzed and contacted media outlets. It is impossible to take steps to address excessive media concentrations and conflicts of interest without the tools to identify the owners.
Suggestions for effective media ownership transparency. The ownership shares of all commercial media analyzed in this study seem to be a mystery. Furthermore, the recommendation encourages states to develop regulatory frameworks to promote transparency of media ownership. The media ownership monitor did a reality check and evaluated if and how media ownership information is available for the general public, as well as how detailed and credible it is. Those company profiles should be updated annually also concerning the structure of the shareholders. This information is not actively publicized by the companies. The media ownership monitor analyzed publicly available data, both online and offline sec documents. Transparencyof media ownership in the eu access info europe. Moreover, public knowledge of media owners identities can. Football clubs, especially when they are in debt, can be attractive targets for criminals seeking to. In order to complete missing data, all media outlets and companies were contacted with a list of followup questions.
The results showed found that in terms of transparency, the government utilizes social media to share video meetings where the public could watch the dynamics of policy formulation and budget. The council of europe has issued guidelines to its 47 member states aimed at assisting them in the promotion of media pluralism and transparency of media ownership. This report is based on a survey of media ownership transparency rules in. Who owns the media in the philippines media ownership. The new report, written by rachael craufurd smith and yolande stolte, presents the results of a project byaccess info europe and the open society program on independent journalism that surveyed of media ownership transparency rules in 20 eu and neighbouring countries in 2012 the authors operated with the understanding that transparency of ownership is an essential prerequisite for the. Transparency of ownership of media houses is only guaranteed at the business registrations and licensing agency brela where the interested members of the public can follow a procedure to request company profiles. Only three companies the stateowned tbc and tsn as well as mwananchi communication limited. Citizens and state authorities have the right to know who owns the individual media outlets in order to prevent a concentration of media power in several hands and abuse of media freedom. Transparency media ownership in ukraine key issue at the. Who owns the media in the philippines media ownership monitor.
Transparency media ownership in ukraine council of europe. While the country enjoys a pluralistic, albeit small print media, georgia lacks a truly pluralistic television sector. Act relating to transparency of media ownership medietilsynet. In short, media transparency reflects the relationship between. Transparency of ownership of legal entities and arrangements is also important in fighting other financial crimes, such as corruption money laundering, and terrorist financing, so that the real owners cannot disguise their activities and hide their assets and the financial trail from law. Monitoring and ensuring ownership pluralism is the first step toward independence and freedom of choice. Mar 07, 2018 the council of europe has issued guidelines to its 47 member states aimed at assisting them in the promotion of media pluralism and transparency of media ownership. This paper suggests opportunities for action, including harmonization of government practices and more guidance for enterprises on transparency and accountability. Transparency of media ownership in dd open society. Report on a project by access info europe and the open society program.
Media ownership monitor lebanon media ownership monitor. The commitment to introduce clear rules on transparency of media ownership in ukraine is part of the euukraine association agenda and the eu would welcome. Transparency of media ownership in turkey wikipedia. Today, georgias media is less free and pluralistic than it was before the rose revolution in 2003 and the ousting of president eduard shevardnadze. In the case of newspapers, the name of the company and publisher.
In 2017 it was announced that televisa would purchase part of the web portal sdpnoticias, which turned from an independent digital blog to becoming a part of the most powerful media group in the country. This problem could be addressed by an amendment of the broadcasting law, in order to ensure that sufficient information about. The purpose of this act is to ensure transparency of ownership interests in norwegian media. No national law media, company, tax contains transparency and disclosure provisions binding media companies to report changes in ownership structures to public authorities, nor to disclose them to the public lists of license holders for tv and print sectors were accessible upon request at. Concentration of media ownership and freedom of expression. Transparency of media ownership in romania wikipedia. Beneficial ownership transparency in corporate formation, shell companies, real estate, and financial transactions beneficial ownership refers to the natural person or persons who invest in, control, or otherwise reap gains from an asset, such as a bank account, real estate property, company, or trust. Media ownership matters mass media influences how facts are viewed and debated in a society, contributing to crafting its public opinion. In morocco, the most responsive media outlets were the online media with 70. Ten recommendations on transparency of media ownership 4 november 20 these recommendations set out the structure for ensuring transparency of media ownership. Consultation on the transparency of the beneficial ownership. The transparency of media ownership in the european union. Furthermore, under article of this act, a transfer of concession to a third party is an o. A legal regime guaranteeing transparency of media ownership makes possible for the public as well as for media authorities to find out who effectively owns, controls and influences the media as well as media influence on political parties or state.
Three ways to fight corruption in the media transparency. Rio tinto is a founding member of the extractive industries transparency initiative eiti, a supporter of the eiti principles and has played an active role in this global standard since 2003 through increased and improved disclosures, eiti seeks to strengthen public and corporate governance, promote understanding of natural resource management and provide the. Findings research by access info europe in 19 european states incl. The information about the editorinchief and ceo are often available, most of the names of the owners can be found in the registry of commerce their shares however not always. Media transparency philippines media ownership monitor. Frequently asked questions media ownership monitor.
Within the media watch program, we drew attention to the threat these issues pose to media pluralism in. As we consider ownership transparency as a crucial precondition to enforce media pluralism, we document the openness of media companiesoutlets to provide information on their ownership structure. Transparency of media ownership in the republic of moldova transparency of media ownership in the republic of moldova instead of a preface. Conflicts of interest between media owners and politics, and a weak regulatory system further pose a threat to freedom of expression in the country. Media ownership monitor egypt media ownership monitor. Lebanese corporations are required to register their minutes of meetings with the commercial register. This is mandatory regarding the approval of annual accounts or the raise or decrease of capital. A series of recommendations show how to increase public access to information. The act shall apply to enterprises which operate daily newspapers, television, radio or electronic media, and to enterprises which through ownership or cooperation agreements have influence over such enterprises. A series of recommendations show how to increase public access to information about media ownership as an essential prerequisite for promoting and protecting media pluralism.
Report on a project by access info europe and the open society program on independent journalism. Independence and pluralism of media, opinions and views including criticism of people in power is the safeguard of a healthy democratic system. The transparency level of each media outlet investigated is indicated on the mom website. The amendments relate to transparency of media ownership. New guidelines on media pluralism and transparency of media. Finding out who are the owners of brazilian radio stations, television channels, newspapers and online portals is not an easy task for common citizens interested in the subject. Analysis of laws and regulations governing transparency of media ownership and. The public availability of accurate, comprehensive, and uptodate data on media ownership is an essential component of a democratic media system.
In a recommendation adopted today, the committee of ministers underlines that advances in modern technology have a profound impact on the functioning of the media sector and on. The information about the editorinchief and ceo are often available, most of the names of the owners can be found in the registry of commerce their shares however. Background information to include in invitation to a. Companies registered in the philippines have to disclose their ownership structures to the securities and exchange commission sec, where that information can be purchased. We believe that greater transparency and accountability helps build trust and encourages sustainable business practices across our industry. One, other g20 efforts such as those initiated by fsb, fatf, oecd and. The media ownership monitor found that a lack of transparency and limited access to ownership information prevail in the media industry in ghana.
Transparency of media ownership is the public availability of accurate, comprehensive and uptodate information about media ownership structures. The consultation document outlined developments and sought views and. Within the media watch program, we drew attention to the threat these issues pose to media pluralism in 2002 based on. As they hold a number of media outlets, we got information on 22% of the outlets. Such fraud and corruption in football are frequently reported in the media, and they. A global framework for tracing beneficial ownership g20. An anamnesis of the transparency of moldovan media ownership transparency and access to information.
With a very opaque market and no law to allow information to be published, egypt faces a number of issues regarding media ownership transparency. Considering their answers, we distinguish different levels of transparency which is indicated for each media outlet and media company on their. Minister of information policy of ukraine yuri stets noted in the speech. Agencies often dont disclose or pass along to their clients rebates also known as agency volume bonuses, or avbs they receive from media companies. The transparency of media ownership in the european union and neighbouring states. The names of the companies that own the media outlets are relatively easy to find. Independence and pluralism in media, public opinion and views including criticism of people in power are the safeguards of a healthy democracy. Access to information is a fundamental human right. Mass media influence the way facts are viewed and debated in the society. Media ownership preface the issues of media ownership concentration and the formulation and implementation of an effective media legislation received considerable attention in recent years.
Despite the legal obligation to disclose certain information about media outlets and companies see regulations, there is only selective transparency. No national law media, company, tax contains transparency and disclosure provisions binding media companies to report changes in ownership structures to public authorities, nor to disclose them to the public. The main aim of the amendments is to obtain correct information about the real owners of media enterprises and to avoid a lack of transparency, e. Television remains the dominant source of information for most georgians. This content is drawn from transparency internationals forthcoming global. Transparency of media ownership in europe wikipedia. Information about media company owners and their shares can be found most of the time in the trade registry gazette archive on ticaretsicil.
The purpose of the fatf standards on transparency and beneficial ownership is to prevent. Media transparency or transparent media, sometimes also referred to as media opacity, is a concept that ponders on how and why information subsidies are being produced, distributed and handled by media professionals, including journalists, editors, public relations practitioners, public affairs specialists, and spokespeople. Over the last year or so, a focus on the beneficial ownership of companies and similar entities, such as foundations has very much come to the fore as part of an international strategy to get to grips with crossborder tax evasion and tax avoidance, corruption, money laundering and other crimes. Unfit, improper ownership in uk football clubs arjun medhi1 introduction moneylaundering and the improper ownership of football clubs are considered among the main threats. The isle of man government invited comment as to whether a centralised registry would improve transparency of the ownership and control of companies in the isle of man.
For the majority 27 of the media outlets and related companies, ownership data was at least publicly available at the sec. Advertisers currently have concerns about agency transparencyor the lack thereofin three primary areas. The transparency of media ownership in the european union and. Beneficial ownership transparency in corporate formation. A global framework for enabling data exchange, crossreferencing, tracing and analysing beneficial owner data on crossborder financial transactions must be established. We support the draft law on transparency of media ownership no. Lists of license holders for tv and print sectors were accessible upon request at the ministry of information. The norwegian media authority shall contribute to create greater transparency, awareness and knowledge of ownership interests in norwegian media. Such fraud and corruption in football are frequently reported in the media, and they involve and affect the wider community, jeopardising the game and its brand value.
Passive transparency means that upon request, ownership data is easily available from the companyfrom a channel. Nov 18, 2016 1 media ownership the ownership of media outlets whether staterun, privately owned, or public service broadcasters is a crucial factor for the independence and integrity of the media. I have consistently supported the initiatives aimed at providing consumer with information about. Being open about our tax payments, mineral development contracts, beneficial ownership and our stance on a range of other sustainability issues like climate change gives us the opportunity to enter into open, factbased, conversations with all of. Consultation on the transparency of the beneficial. Transparency of media ownership refers to the public availability of accurate, comprehensive and uptodate information about media ownership structures to make possible for media authorities and the wider public to ascertain who effectively owns and controls the media. Sec2007 32, media pluralism in the member states of the.
1341 484 770 506 104 405 1371 1399 392 1038 371 1294 982 333 1352 1347 1163 921 82 120 1158 818 1368 830 1182 346 1130 1072 999 1051 1441 402 1409 1453 513 626 1361 345 24 1259